Why William Grimes Wrote to John Quincy Adams

In 1825, Lifetime of William Grimes, the Runaway Slave, Written by Himself turned the primary recognized fugitive-slave narrative in American historical past. Though earlier autobiographical accounts of slavery had been printed in England, the style wouldn’t totally flourish in the USA till the antislavery motion of the 1830s to 1860s, when such narratives turned highly effective instruments of ethical persuasion, exposing the brutality of bondage whereas asserting the author’s humanity, mind, and can. William Grimes wrote earlier than that second, introducing a distinctly American voice formed by the horrors of enslavement within the South and the precariousness of freedom within the North. What he printed was greater than a memoir—it was an indictment of the contradictions that had been central to the American experiment because the Revolution itself.

For 30 years, I’ve been researching the life and legacy of Grimeswho was my third great-grandfather. In Might 2024, throughout my closing week as a analysis fellow at Yale’s Beinecke Library, I made a visit to the Boston Athenaeum to see a replica of his guide that had been housed there since 1849 and remained unexamined by students for 175 years. This copy, I’d discovered, had been addressed to President John Quincy Adams. I had no means of realizing whether or not the sixth president had learn Grimes’s narrative. However discovering the truth that Grimes had needed him to see it moved me in methods I hadn’t anticipated.

Grimes’s story opens with bitter irony:

“In all of the Slave States,” Grimes wrote, “the youngsters comply with the situation of their mom.” Although his father, Benjamin Grymes Jr., was a rich white Virginia planter, William remained enslaved like his mom—legally the property of a person he calls Dr. Stuart, Grymes’s neighbor. He recalled carrying newspapers to his father, who would communicate and snigger with him and ship him to the kitchen for one thing to eat. No matter endearment younger William could have felt, Benjamin Grymes neither owned, bought, nor freed his enslaved son.

Learn: A 168-year-old query nonetheless price asking

At 10 years outdated, William was offered by Dr. Stuart to Colonel William Thornton, his brother-in-law, and despatched to a distant plantation in what’s now Rappahannock County. He grew up, as he later wrote, friendless and motherless, formed early by violence and starvation. Inside the home, the pinnacle servant and seamstress sabotaged him to advance her personal little one; within the fields, overseers beat him for the slightest offense. When he was 12 or 13, he ran away to flee a brutal overseer, hiding in a hole log for 3 days till he gave himself up, deciding that he “would possibly as properly be whipped to demise as to starve.” Hardened by slavery, he grew up defiant.

He later implied that he couldn’t be ruled in the best way that slavery was meant, writing that he had “an excessive amount of sense and feeling to be a slave.” He stated that he carried “an excessive amount of of the blood of my father,” a former “Life Guard” to George Washington, “whose spirit feared nothing.” Over time, Grimes handed by the arms of 10 enslavers—from Dr. Stuart to Colonel Thornton and two of his sons, then to 6 interconnected businessmen in Savannah, Georgia.

In 1815, alternative—not planning—opened a path to freedom. Left to rent out his time whereas his enslaver vacationed in Bermuda, Grimes went to the Savannah harbor in search of work. With discreet assist from Black “Yankee” sailors who befriended him, he hid amongst cotton bales within the maintain of a brig referred to as the Casket because it set course for Quarantine Floor, off Staten Island. Evading inspection, the sailors helped him attain a packet boat sure for New York Metropolis. From there, Grimes walked some 80 miles to New Haven, Connecticut.

For almost a decade, he lived within the shadows—all the time vigilant, all the time in danger, but decided to construct a life. He was a servant at Yale Faculty; he minimize hair, and ultimately established a barbering enterprise in Litchfield; purchased property; married Clarissa Caesar; and began a household. Barbering—a Black man’s commerce—gave him entry to discovered males: Yale college students, authorized minds at Tapping Reeve’s legislation college in Litchfield, and political leaders, together with Connecticut Governor Oliver Wolcott Jr.

Grimes moved recurrently by areas the place concepts circulated and energy was formed. All of the whereas, he lived with the data that his freedom might be revoked at any second. In September 1823, that concern turned actuality when his former enslaver F. H. Welman, aided by Savannah enterprise companions, situated him. Going through the prospect of seizure and return to the South, Grimes provided his small, debt-burdened home—the extent of his property—to stay together with his spouse and kids.

Negotiations stretched throughout Connecticut, Georgia, New York, and the District of Columbia. Welman valued Grimes at $800 however agreed to just accept $500. But even that lowered sum was past Grimes’s speedy attain.

Letters preserved on the Litchfield Historic Society level to an preliminary association born of necessity: a down cost, doubtless from the sale of his residence, adopted by installments extending almost a yr. The ultimate phrases below which Grimes succeeded in buying his personal physique stay unknown, though it’s sure that he misplaced his residence within the course of. Till the ultimate cost was made, his freedom was provisional; re-enslavement was an ever-present risk.

At the Athenaeum, I used to be led to a studying desk and handed Tracts Quantity IV—a sure assortment of pamphlets as soon as owned by President John Quincy Adams and donated to the library in 1849 by his son Charles Francis Adams. Inside have been sermons, political tracts, and academic booklets. Then I noticed it. A small handwritten word lay tucked inside Lifetime of William Grimesresting immediately atop the title web page. The penmanship was assured, confident; the signature unmistakable: Wm. Grimes. A darkish inkblot marked the word—his hand on the web page two centuries in the past:

To grasp the total weight of that ink, I wanted to grasp what had led as much as this second.

In 1824, the celebrated French aristocrat Basic Lafayette—a hero of the American Revolution—returned to the USA at President James Monroe’s invitation for a sweeping farewell tour designed to rekindle patriotic devotion in a brand new technology. Wherever Lafayette traveled, parades and speeches proclaimed the USA the world’s beacon of liberty. On August 12, the overall was greeted in New Haven with patriotic fervor. Governor Wolcott was there to welcome him.

Whether or not or not Grimes, the governor’s barber, attended the festivities himself, he was shut sufficient to the celebrations to really feel the satisfaction of liberty collide together with his actuality as he labored towards buying his personal freedom. We can not know exactly when he started writing, however his guide’s preface is dated October 1, 1824, lower than two months after Lafayette’s go to. By January 1825, Grimes had deposited the finished manuscript with the clerk of the District of Connecticut.

Two months later, on March 4, 1825, the newly inaugurated President John Quincy Adams made reference to a nationwide “jubilee” to mark the fiftieth anniversary of the formation of the USA. His speech learn like a progress report on the republic’s first half century. Concerning slavery, nonetheless, Adams balanced his personal antislavery convictions towards the proslavery stance of his vp, John C. Calhoun. The brand new president trod rigorously, acknowledging solely obliquely the authorized finish of the transatlantic slave commerce in 1808.

Learn: Frederick Douglass, refugee

Grimes absolutely would have learn Adams’s inaugural speech. He understood properly that the written phrase was energy—that books and newspapers formed public thought and conferred authority. His life reveals how charged literacy was on the planet he navigated. As an adolescent, he was brutally crushed for carving letters into an outside oven whereas the mortar was nonetheless moist. In Savannah, he was employed out to the household of P. D. Woolhopter, a co-founder of Savannah’s Columbian Museuma Federalist newspaper. As a fugitive in New Haven, he boldly marketed his barbering enterprise within the Connecticut Herald. And in early August 1825, he positioned an advert for his guide, addressed “To the Public,” within the Connecticut Journalprinting the gripping preface in full. His commercial ended with a drumbeat: “On the market on the Bookstores on this metropolis.” In 1825, for a previously enslaved man to publicly declare authorship and promote his guide in white-owned bookstores was to plant a flag of freedom in hostile floor. It declared: I’m right here. I can’t be hidden or silenced.

Within the context of the approaching nationwide milestone—earlier than parades, fireworks, and hovering speeches saluted the nation’s fiftieth anniversary—Grimes’s resolution to ship the guide to Adams with a proper word appeared like a rigorously aimed stone on the glass of America’s triumphal story. Once I returned to the opening line of his narrative, I noticed it in a different way—what as soon as gave the impression to be a easy starting now commanded deeper scrutiny: I used to be born within the yr 1784 in J_____.

For years, I’d assumed the J stood for a spot. However what if it meant January? On January 14, 1784, the Treaty of Paris was ratified—the nation’s first authorized breath of freedom. Grimes later admitted that he couldn’t inform his spouse his true age; most enslaved folks by no means knew their beginning yr, not to mention their full date of beginning. What if, by tying himself to the historic month of January 1784, he had been intentionally aligning his life with the beginning of the republic? Was this a part of the message he needed the president to soak up?

The pages that adopted Grimes’s well mannered presidential dedication—Relying in your Excellency’s generosity—shattered any veneer of civility, exposing the truth of Grimes’s life as an enslaved man from the South and the fragility of survival within the so-called free North. Grimes’s narrative is uncooked and unsparing, laying naked not solely relentless bodily violence but additionally psychological trauma with no time or refuge to heal. He closes his guide with a passage that strips jubilee rhetoric of all deception:

If Adams learn these phrases in 1826, he would have encountered a direct problem to his personal language of triumph. Adams, a person who believed in ethical legislation however typically deferred motion, would have been pressured to confront slavery not as a distant coverage downside however as a constitutional failure written in human flesh. Maybe, I imagined, Grimes’s phrases had managed, nonetheless fleetingly, to reveal the gulf between the nation’s self-congratulation at 50 years and the violence required to maintain its freedom.

Learn: ‘Come out and see the celebs’

Adams would later start to problem that contradiction extra overtly. By the late 1830s, free of presidential constraint, he was battling the congressional gag rule that sought to silence any point out of slavery, and in 1841 he stood earlier than the Supreme Court docket to defend the Amistad captives and demand on their proper to freedom.

We are going to doubtless by no means know whether or not Adams learn Grimes’s guide. But it surely was not discarded. It was handed on to his son, and it was trimmed and sure, preserved. One thing in it had mattered—and nonetheless does immediately.